Here's what Mayor
Bloomberg had to say today about the court
ruling:
STATEMENT BY MAYOR MICHAEL R. BLOOMBERG ON TODAY’S APPELLATE DIVISION
RULING ON THE REVIEW AND APPROVAL OF ATLANTIC YARDS PROJECT
"The Atlantic Yards project will create thousands of jobs and generate
badly-needed tax revenue. The court’s unanimous affirmation today that
the review and approvals processes were comprehensive and properly completed
is a big step towards the start of construction."**
Here's what the court's
ruling had to say about elected folks, such as the Mayor:
..."While we do not agree with petitioners' legal arguments, we understand
those arguments to be made largely as proxies for very legitimate concerns
as to the effect of a project of such scale upon the face and social fabric
of the area in which it is to be put. Those concerns, however, have relatively
little to do with the project's legality and nearly everything to do with
its socio-economic and aesthetic desirability, matters upon which we may not
pass. To the extent that the fate of this multi-billion dollar project
remains, in an increasingly forbidding economy, a matter of social and political
volition, the controlling judgments as to its merits are the province of the
policy-making branches of government, not the courts."
(Emphasis added.)
That sounds like a challenge to the Mayor and other elected officials to do more
than simply accept that legal Ts were crossed and legal Is were dotted. That is
the purview of the court. The Mayor's purview is sound policy. We wonder, with
great concern, what the sound policy is that underlies the Atlantic Yards proposal,
that underlies a publicly-subsidized billlion dollar arena in the midst of the
Great Recession. An arena which, by the way, would be a financial
loss for the City. We wonder what the merits are and who, if anyone, is judging
them outside of Forest City Ratner spin.
** Note well that the Mayor's release makes no mention of housing of any kind—market
or affordable. Those, of course, are on the backburner, and the pilot
light is flickering.